Here's some video evidence of Matthew Sweet(tooth)'s newfound girth, from an April 2006 appearance on "The Tonight Show with Jay Leno's Chin":
BORU is right -- Matthew Sweet looks like he stole John Popper's cookbook. And then ate it.
But, what I'm more surprised at is that Susanna Hoffs is STILL HOT! She's gotta be, like, 50, but she still looks like she did when she was walking like an Egyptian in my room on manic mondays (tho' maybe a bit more Botox'd).
-RAM